Sunday, March 7, 2021

Metropolis Discussion



My Essay on Metropolis:

German Expressionist filmmakers focused on stylizing their mise-en-scène in a way to reject realism and express emotional reality. The filmmakers mirrored the Expressionist painting, theater and graphic design of the era.

While many directors of that time used distortion in their sets, sagging or leaning buildings. Fritz Lang’s did use this style occasionally but used more elongation and artistic symmetry with huge grand scale tall sets. I compare these shots from two of his films.


 This shot is from his earlier film Siegfried (Fritz Lang, 1924) has an elongated set and there is perfect symmetry of the steps and the princess standing in the middle with two maidens on the sides. Paralleling Metropolis’ narrative, when the princess stands in the doorway, it is a great dramatic moment. The enormous arguing crowds go silent respect and reverence. 


In Metropolis (Fritz Lang, 1927) while there is distortion in the catacombs, the shot is very centered and symmetrical. Maria is in the middle of a candle lit altar and proportionally centered within the middle square blocks on the steps. The set is elongated with a tall ceiling. Most of the Metropolis had strong vertical lines with symmetry which is a style of Fritz Lang (Thompson and Bordwell p. 91). In this narrative as well, this is very dramatic moment with all the men in silence and reverence of Maria.   

The Kammerspiel films, in contrast, did not show dramatic moments as in the above Metropolis scene. In Backstairs (Leopold Jessner, 1921) there is a lot of thought and ponderance by the postman, but the climax of the clip we saw is him staring at the woman and giving her a piece of mail. The indoor sets also seem cramped and not as much of an important element as Expressionists

Casting by the hundreds was used mainly in German Spectacle films just before Expressionism. I found that Lang emulated Ernst Lubitsch use of hundreds of extras in mise-en-scène. In the spectacle film Madame DuBarry (Ernst Lubitsch, 1919) just before the storming of the Bastille, the scene is covered with revolutionaries in every space of the village.

Fritz Lang used a huge cavalry and court in Siegfried. The hundreds of workers in Metropolis, as well their matching dark clothing against lighter backdrops, made spectacular visual scenes.

Response from Brian Clark

Hello Ida,

You are very right about how symmetrical a lot of the shots are, I first noticed it with the buildings and later realized that the use of symmetry applied to other scenes as well. Metropolis had a lot going on when it came to spectacular visuals, the hundreds of workers added a sense of scale, for a city that size the idea would not have worked without a mass amount of people especially when the workers were rioting.

Response from Kevin Rojas

Hey Ida, 

That's a good point you made about how a lot of the scenes the shots or the camera angle were placed in symmetrical directions. Metropolis was one crazy film at the time it was released with all these special effects going on. I wonder how long this took to film this movie with the technology they had back then 


My response to Brian

Hello Brian,

I think it was important, as you did, to mention The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari (Robert Weine, 1920)  which the text says "remained the most famous Expressionist film."  It showed distortions and "the style was used mainly for conveying character subjectivity."

I also appreciated the discussion of the dream sequence and how interesting it was shot. I remember this very similar shot in Secrets of a Soul (G. W. Pabst, 1926)soul23.png  

Where the guys is dreaming and has these faces staring at him in his dream. 

I agree that the eye collage seems like it would be a hard edit to create. I don't know how they did that. 


Your Answers:

Results for item 1.

1 point possible

What German director is associated with both the Expressionist and New Objectivity film movements?

Waiting for grade

G.W. Pabst 

Waiting for grade

Results for item 2.

1 point possible

What film featured in the Module is about a hotel doorman who is demoted at work? The film also serves as an example of moving camera in the Module.

Waiting for grade

The Last Laugh (F. W. Murnau, 1924)

Waiting for grade

Results for item 3.

1 point possible

What film is generally considered the first Expressionist film according to Thompson and Bordwell?

Waiting for grade

The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari (Robert Weine, 1920)

Waiting for grade

Results for item 4.

1 point possible

Who is the character on the right in the following shot from Metropolis?

 

Waiting for grade

Hel - Rotwang had been in love with her but she married Mr. Frederson. Rotwang created this robot of her.

Waiting for grade

Results for item 5.

1 point possible

Who is this character from Metropolis and where is she in the following shot from the film?

 

Waiting for grade

This is Maria - she is in the catacombs talking to the workers

Waiting for grade

Metropolis

 Metropolis


Metropolis

Click here - Trailer of the new Kino version of Metropolis we saw

There have been several different versions of Metropolis released over the year. This is the Complete Metropolis released in 2010. Details about the restoration of this cut from Wikipedia below:

On 1 July 2008 film experts in Berlin announced that a 16 mm reduction negative of the original cut had been discovered in the archives of the Museo del Cine in Buenos Aires, Argentina. The negative was a safety reduction made in the 1960s or 1970s from a 35 mm positive of Lang's original version, which an Argentinian film distributor had obtained in advance of arranging theatrical engagements in South America. The safety reduction was intended to safeguard the contents in case the original's flammable nitrate film stock was destroyed. The negative was passed to a private collector, an art foundation and finally the Museo del Cine.


The print was investigated by the Argentinian film collector/historian and TV presenter Fernando Martín Peña, along with Paula Felix-Didier, the head of the museum, after Peña heard an anecdote from a cinema club manager expressing surprise at the length of a print of Metropolis he had viewed. The print was indeed Lang's full original, with about 25 minutes of footage, around one-fifth of the film, that had not been seen since 1927.


Under the auspices of the Friedrich-Wilhelm-Murnau-Stiftung, Berlin's Deutsche Kinemathek and Museo del Cine, a group of experts, including Anke Wilkening, Martin Koerber, and Frank Strobel began combining the newly discovered footage with the existing footage from the 2001 restoration. A major problem was that the Argentinian footage was in poor condition and had many scratches, streaks, and changes in brightness. Some of this they were able to overcome with digital technology, which would not have been possible in 2001. The reconstruction of the film with the new footage was once again accompanied by the original music score, including Huppertz's handwritten notes, which acted as the key resource in determining the places in which the restored footage would go. Since the Argentinian print was a complete version of the original, some scenes from the 2001 restoration were put in different places than previously, and the tempo of the original editing was restored.


In 2005, Australian historian and politician Michael Organ had examined a print of the film in the National Film Archive of New Zealand. Organ discovered that the print contained scenes missing from other copies of the film. After hearing of the discovery of the Argentine print of the film and the restoration project, Organ contacted the German restorers; the New Zealand print contained 11 missing scenes and featured some brief pieces of footage that were used to restore damaged sections of the Argentine print. It is believed that the New Zealand and Argentine prints were all sourced from the same master. The newly-discovered footage was used in the restoration project. The Argentine print was in poor condition and required considerable restoration before it was re-premiered in February 2010. Two short sequences, depicting a monk preaching and a fight between Rotwang and Fredersen, were damaged beyond repair. Title cards describing the action were inserted by the restorers to compensate. The Argentine print revealed new scenes that enriched the film's narrative complexity. The characters of Josaphat, the Thin Man, and 11811 appear throughout the film and the character Hel is reintroduced.


The 2010 restoration was premiered on 12 February 2010 at the Berlin Friedrichstadtpalast. Huppertz's score was performed by the Berlin Radio Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Frank Strobel, who also re-recorded it for theatrical and home video release. The performance was a gala screening as part of the 60th Berlinale and had several simultaneous screenings. It was also shown on an outdoor screen at Berlin's Brandenburg Gate, as well as at the Alte Oper in Frankfurt am Main. The Brandenburg Gate screening was also telecast live by the Arte network. The North American premiere took place at the 2010 TCM Classic Film Festival in Mann's Chinese Theatre in Los Angeles on 25 April 2010.


The restoration has a running time of 148 minutes (or nearly 2.5 hours) and was released internationally on various DVD and Blu-ray editions beginning in 2010.

Saturday, March 6, 2021

G. W. Pabst and New Objectivity

 G. W. Pabst and New Objectivity

1920-24
1)The production of Expressionist films was most intense between 1920 and 1924.
2)During the final years of the trend, only two such films were released,
3)both made by Ufa:
   a)Murnau’s Faust and
   b)Lang’s Metropolis.
4)The latter’s release in January 1927 marked the end of the movement.
5)Two major factors in Expressionism’s decline were
   a)the excessive budgets of the later films and
   b)the departure of the main Expressionist filmmakers to Hollywood.

Changing Cultural Climate
1)A further reason for the decline of Expressionism lies in the changing cultural climate
   of Germany.
2)Most art historians date the end of the movement in painting around 1924.
3)The style had been current for about a decade and a half and had gradually filtered
   into the popular arts and design.
4)It became too familiar to retain its status as an avant-garde style, and
5)artists turned in more vital directions.

New Objectivity
1)Many artists moved away from the contorted emotionalism of Expressionism
    toward realism and cool-headed social criticism.
2)The trend was called “New Objectivity” (Neue Sachlichkeit).
3)The savage political caricatures of George Grosz and Otto Dix
    are considered central to New Objectivity.

New Objectivity in Cinema
1)In the cinema, New Objectivity took various forms.
2)One trend usually linked to New Objectivity was the street film.
3)In such films, characters from sheltered middle-class backgrounds
   are suddenly exposed to the environment of city streets,
   where they encounter representatives of various social ills,
    such as
   a)prostitutes,
   b)gamblers,
   c)black marketeers, and
   d)con men.

Street Films
1)Street films came to prominence in 1923 with the success of Karl Grune’s The Street.
2)It tells the simple story of a middle-aged man’s psychological crisis.
3) From the safety of his apartment, he sees visions of the excitement and romance that may
    be awaiting him in the street.
4)Slipping away from his wife, he explores the city, only to be lured by a prostitute into a den
    of cardsharps.
5)Eventually he returns home, but the ending leaves the sense that the denizens of the street
    lurk threateningly nearby.

The Street (Karl Grune, 1923)

                                            The man slips out and sees strange things
This lady is checking him out
He's looking at the big eye sign and getting scared - good shadows
People are going into this building - he follows - them or the woman not sure
                                    The woman walks into her box seat - the band is playing
                                    on the 2nd balcony to the right, the people are dancing below
                                    He's summoning up the courage to go inside
                                    He walks in - modestly dressed, others nicer. - to the left there is a bar
He goes up to her box seat - looking for her?
                     The whole scene spins left and upside down then right upside down many times
He can't handle it. 
his vision is still spinning
He sees the lady - he's approaching her table
he just sits down. 
he looks at her dress and raises his eyebrows
oh no, trouble from this guy
He stands up to shake their hands and they grab a chair instead
She puts her arms around both guys!
She looks him up and down and kind of laughs
This place is beautiful
The guy doesn't know what to do or how to socialize he's uncomfortable
Sooo many screen shots - but this place is beautiful - I'm sure it was all gone after wwii
                                       Some other guys come to the table to make fun of him
She's trying to look past him to a rich guy drinking champagne and eating chocolate - he keeps moving his head to block her view
The rich guy comes over and sits at the table - the guy looks upset
He puts her back toward her -- she just laughs -- the guys all point to his wedding ring - the rich guy pulls his out of his pocket to show him where to keep it.
She's flirting with the rich guy putting his hands on his face
The guy takes off his ring and sees a vision of him and his wife
She starts backing out of the vision into the dark
He finally has regret
Just then she puts his arm around him and they all start toasting him.
End of clip

G.W. Pabst
1)The most celebrated German director of the mid-1920s, G. W. Pabst,
2)rose to fame when he made the second major street film, The Joyless Street.
3)Another major example was
   Bruno Rahn’s Dirnentragödie (“Whore’s Tragedy,” aka Tragedy of the Street, 1928).
4) In it the enduring Danish star Asta Nielsen plays an aging prostitute who takes in a
     rebellious middle-class runaway;
5)she dreams of a new life with him.
6)He returns to his parents, and she is arrested for murdering her pimp.
7)The film used dark studio sets,
    a moving camera, and
    close framings
8)to create the oppressive atmosphere of back streets and dingy apartments.

Pabst's Der Schatz
1)G. W. Pabst’s first feature was in the Expressionist style: Der Schatz (“The Treasure,”
   1923).
2)His next, The Joyless Street (1925), remains the most widely seen of the street films.
3)Set in Vienna during the period of hyperinflation,
4)the film follows the fates of two women:
5)Greta, the middle-class daughter of a civil servant, and
6)Maria, a woman from a poverty-ridden home.
7)When Greta’s father loses his money, she is nearly prostituted,
8)while Maria becomes the mistress of a rich man.
9)The Joyless Street portrays the era’s financial chaos,
10)perhaps most vividly in the scenes of women lining up to buy meat from a callous butcher
    who extorts sexual favors in exchange for food.
11)(Owing to the film’s controversial subject matter, it was often censored abroad, and
     truncated versions still circulate.)

Pabst’s subsequent career was uneven.
1)He turned out some ordinary films, such as the conventional triangle melodrama
    Crisis (1928).
2)However, his Secrets of a Soul (1926) was the first serious attempt to apply
   the tenets of the new Freudian school of psychoanalysis in a film narrative
.
3)This desire for a scientific approach to psychological problems
    marks Secrets of a Soul as another variant of the New Objectivity.

Secrets of a Soul intro
1)It is virtually a case study, following a seemingly ordinary man who develops a knife
   phobia and seeks treatment from a psychoanalyst.
2)Though the depiction of psychoanalysis is oversimplified,
3)the Expressionist style of some of the dream sequences adds considerable interest to the
   film.

Secrets of a Soul (G. W. Pabst, 1926)
This guy is in a tree looking into a house
This guy comes out - he is sleep walking
or maybe not - he saw the guy in the tree and ran back inside
The door is locked
The tree guy gave him a huge evil smile
He's freaking out - good shadows
Evil man in tree is making come here! signs with hands - oh
a gun appears in his hand. 
pj guy jumps surreally in mid-air
Now he's over a chess set - that's the pattern of his outside patio
He flies high into the sky and then is shot and comes crashing down.
Then he wakes up - no - he's having another nightmare
He walks through this tunnel - nice shot
Still in his pajamas
Now there's a latch that comes down and stops him
There great train scene happens
it starts like it's coming to him and then swirls and wraps around
The same mean guy takes off his hat and is waving at him through a train window
I don't know how they did this shot
The gate lifts up - he runs to this altar
She seems to shake her head at him
He grabs something out of his pocket
An intertitle says: 
Sincerely
Your Cousin Hans
He throws the card - it turns into a fire and puff of smoke
He runs past the statue
Another vision of a train
Now he's dressed for work
A little town is springing up and growing like seeds to plants and a gazebo floats up in the middle spiraling-- rain tickle music
It keeps spiraling up into the sky
He runs up to it - great shot
He looks up and three church bells are clanging up at the top
The view changes from low looking up to a vertical view of bells
now the faces of the bells - turn into faces of strange women
He runs past the large tower - no - up the stairs - cool shot I love the shapes contrasting colors and shadows
repeating shot of this- then he reaches top to stop the bells from ringing
he does - he looks down to see this...
He starts yelling and banging his hands down - i've taken too many screen shots or i'd take it
The faces start to laugh at him
Screen blacks out - he's in bed again
His wife is sleeping on her side of the room
There is lightning flashing on and off in seconds each - here is one
The guy is twisting in his bed
nightmare again - he walks up to this murder scene or rape taking place
He keeps trying to stop it by banging his cane
He keeps banging his cane on the ledge. Camera view goes from close-up of the silhoutes and close up of his face
(NOT MANY INTERTITLES AT ALL)
He grabs the hand rails and they start growing and taking him up in the air
He is high above the house - holding onto the handrail.
He is right below the word "of"
Next is a front view of him holding onto the gate  - trying to stay on. 
The evil tree man comes in a vision and points down
Whoa - then this happened
In the middle under the drums - i think it's the clown Pierrot moving
Then - this happens
oh, back to the drums - he is the one standing in the back below the drums - i don't know for sure
Know this lady starts to do something strange to her head - when the puppet points to her
Now the puppet points to the guys on the left
and they walk up the guy under the drum - not the puppet - the sleeping guy and point at 
his -- i love the distortion and shadows
Thank God, I think he's waking up - that was only 5:29 min of film
No - he falls back asleep 
A speedy locomotive is coming right to him
Now it is daylight - dream - reality? It looks like a doctor's office
The but it's the guy - he stacks his books on the ground to see inside a cell - good shadows
There he sees lilly pads in water - Now back
shot to the guy freaking out 
A boat comes up through the lilly pads
he's looking at it
I'm pretty sure it's the evil guy on the boat with his wife
A baby jumps out of the pond into her lap - or she pulled him out
she's cradling it and puts it up to her cheek - the bad guy has his arm around her
He takes the baby from her and cradles it - 
shot back to the guy yelling from the cell window
They sail under him - smiling and waving
He runs back to the table and grabs a HUGE knife

Then a fairy or vision of a woman appears to talk to him
No - it's his wife waving from the boat - he keeps trying to stab her and she keeps on waving
NOW, he wakes up -- sits up quick in his bed and screams a lot
His wife runs in - puts her arms around him
INTERTITLE: "I dreamt things -- It was horrible -- !"
He lays his head on her lap and she pats his head
End of clip - That's the most screen shots I've ever taken - it was beautiful!

Here's a link to the full film - click here

The real end of the film is him talking it over with a psychiatrist and the unlock the meanings

Pabst also made another major New Objectivity film,
1)The Love of Jeanne Ney, in 1928.
2)The film’s famous opening exemplifies what critics admired in his work.
3)Rather than showing the villain immediately, the sequence begins with a tightly framed
   panning shot that builds a quick sense of his character through details.
4)The first shot of The Love of Jeanne Ney, moving from the villain’s worn shoes propped
   carelessly against the woodwork,
5)to his hand searching the litter on a table for a cigarette butt, and to him lighting up,
6)with a liquor bottle prominent in the foreground.

The Love of Jeanne Ney (G. W. Pabst, 1928)
First shot as per notes above
2nd shot discussed above
3rd shot noted above
Cuts away to this nightclub
Lots of guys drinking in uniforms pans the room
at 0:54 a kosak smoking
Well this is interesting.
a bottle was passed up - it pans up as bottle is passed up
This woman's pose though
Very interesting how they changed camera positions now to top looking down
Close-ups again on the Kosak - Is he the villain from 1st scene? - no
The club is going wild - people standing on table..
The villain lives on the top floor and someone is delivering him booze - 
He gives him his exotic pipe in exchange for bottle.
A woman without a bra slides down the banister
He pokes his head out from his room - note the interesting phone and mirror
He looks at the crowd and seems to get upset
A window cracks - did he throw something - the kosak is staring at him in broken glass
The thief guy smiles and closes his door - odd
Kosak is at his door - confronting him
Gives him the book on the phone - did he walk in his room?
End of clip
Decline of New Objectivity
1)Number of factors led to the decline of New Objectivity in the cinema.
2)For one thing, the increasing domination of German politics by extreme right-wing forces
    in the late 1920s and early 1930s resulted in a wider split between conservative and
    liberal factions.
3)Socialist and Communist groups made films that provided an outlet for strong social
   criticism.
4)Moreover, the coming of sound combined with greater control over the film industry by
   conservative forces to create an emphasis on light entertainment.
5)The operetta genre became one of the most prominent types of sound filmmaking,
6)and social realism became rare.